REVIEW — She Came Back Different (Stephanie Willing)

I think that, in some way, it’s every girl’s dream to be the belle of the ball. To be graceful, kindhearted, funny, wanted… perfect. For girls attending the prestigious Stadler Ballet Conservatory, their initial wildflower tendencies — through a mix of ballet, education, hard work, and a touch of evergreen magic — are transformed. Author Stephanie Willing’s middle-grade gothic tale She Came Back Different is the story of six such girls who find that being perfect isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be when this conservatory promises that transformation in exchange for their inner identity.

In a tale alternating between their perspectives, both girls must brave a world of rules and conformity. One in which beauty hides a hideous and sinister truth that will devour their very souls if they cannot overcome their differences. Can they embrace each other’s flaws and their own in order to dig up the school’s rotten roots and unmask what’s really growing . . . and feeding . . . behind Stadler’s walls?

She Came Back Different

Accident-prone Gemma, hard-as-a-nail Neve, cool and smart Chloe, eager and skilled Kris, friendly and sweet Esther, and quiet and secretive Ivy are the newest group admitted into the Stadler Ballet Conservatory, what is basically the cream of the crop for dance schools, promising to turn even the most unathletic, unflattering student into a prima ballerina. Hidden in lush greenery and spoken about in hushed voices, Stadler feels unsettling instead of welcome — especially considering the Madames in bright, singular-toned clothing and robotic returning students. Gemma and Neve, two opposing forces, soon find out why: the twisted vines covering the school have a monstrous effect on the students, and the Madames are in on it. Soliciting the help from the other four newcomers, the girls utilize teamwork (and their own boost in confidence and comradery) to free the students from the crippling hold the school has on them. Their lives — and their personalities — depend on it.

foot in pointe shoe standing in grass among daisi
Photo by Matt Stone on Pexels.com

She Came Back Different may not be the book every girl wants to read, but it’s one I think every girl should. And not only every girl, every kid regardless of gender. Bouncing back and forth between two total opposites, Gemma and Neve, this book delivers on everything from girly ideals to incomprehensible horrors to mysteries and action alike. And it somehow wraps up a very important message in all of it: you are perfect just as you are. Each of the six newcomers are presented with their own little worlds, with backstory, wants and needs, and motives for their actions. And in turn, they each go through their own journey, meeting everyone else at the end. She Came Back Different brilliantly showed how our differences are ultimately strengths, and how it’s OK to want something better, just as long as it doesn’t take away the true you.

This book was surprisingly scary for a middle-grade reader. She Came Back Different involves mysterious, chemically altered, magical, man-eating plants that essentially suck the personality and life out of its victims, instead filling those voids with “perfect” (i.e., moldable and agreeable) likelinesses. In a similar way to Suspiria, the dances done at the school work to subdue the girls while the plants take over. Multiple times throughout the book are we given passages detailing the writhing agony the girls are in as they are attacked every night. And even in non-horror moments — such as any interaction with the upperclassmen — their tones and actions are so robotic, clean, and uncanny that we lose more and more hope the longer the story goes on.

And on and on it does go. She Came Back Different is just shy of 300 pages, so for its target audience, I wouldn’t necessarily say it’s a one-day read. That said, this book was so hard to put down. There are cliffhangers at every chapter end, and each switch between characters’ perspectives offers a new look at what just happened and what is to come. I found a part of myself in each and every one of the girls, and I had ample room to love, get angry with, and cheer for them. With personality being the main topic of this book, Willing did an amazing job and making each girl their own person and easy to empathize with. And even if that weren’t the case, I was still wholly engrossed in the descriptions of wooden hallways with stale air, brightly lit stages, and towns filled with the smells and tastes of an autumnul wonderland.

She Came Back Different isn’t just a ballerina book. It’s a story about perseverance and growth, and how that doesn’t just stop once you leave a certain section of your life. Just as we continue to learn and creep into each new phase of our lives, the trees outside of the Stadler Conservatory continue to widen their branches and healing nature, and the girls come back for that breath of fresh air, ready to start a new chapter. She Came Back Different was exciting, thrilling, and important.

She Came Back Different is available for purchase on Amazon. For more, visit author Stephanie Willing on web and follow on Instagram.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *